Vegetable Garden Retaining Walls are a hot topic in our home these days as we need to replace a part of the rotting wood walls in our steep veggie garden. Thanks to Theresa for writing and asking me about this subject and what to use. I am not an expert, but have my preferences. Here is part of my response and thoughts to a great question:

Vegetable Garden Background
When we moved to our current home more than a decade ago, the retaining walls were already installed. We believe that the pine wood logs used were preserved so more than likely they were chemically treated. Some are now reaching the end of their life and will need to be replaced or repaired. The top two rows are in good condition and are square 4 x 6" lengths and appear to be just fine.
We are looking for alternatives which are not expensive – a big challenge so far. One neighbour has installed a concrete wall (about 4 ft high), another has used pressure treated railway ties with creosote – a probable carcinogenic. Definitely not “organic” or healthy. The direction we are heading in at present is for some form of bricks (perhaps recycled).
For us a simple alternative: The bottom gardens with the steep slope are no longer used as much for vegetables. We have six new raised beds on our level grass area close to the house. https://caramelandparsley.ca/new-raised-bed-gardens-for-spring/ the latest being a 4 x 8 feet bed which is wonderful. The wood we used is untreated Non toxic pine 4 x 4 ft. long – 2 x 6” so the beds are 12” high and we dug down into the lawn another foot before adding compost & soil. We would have liked cedar but it is much more expensive. We used half our back lawn for this project.
Retaining Wall Options & Thoughts
Personally I like metal containers and if money were no object I would go for the bricks. Just not sure how strong they would be as the height of the retaining wall is about 30 to 36 inches.
Note 1: Our new raised beds allow the garden veggies to be rotated each year
Note 2: When we lived on 5 acres in Northern BC it was very heavily treed with fir, poplar & pine. Some trees had to be cleared and were recycled (untreated) into making 4 x 8 feet raised beds as well as compost containers. It was a most incredible garden

Options for Retaining Wall and Raised Beds
Here is a list of options I have come across. There is a mountain of information on the internet and if you question staff at various hardware stores and landscaping companies you will be able to choose what you are comfortable with. Note that creosote and other chemically pressure treated products are not recommended - ever - not just for organic (chemical free) vegetable, fruit and flower gardens.
- Wood - several options from pine to cedar - of course untreated wood products do not last as long as chemically treated walls or raised bed containers
- Bricks - small or large
- Concrete (for larger walls)
- Metal bins (for raised beds)
- There are other environmental options some which appear more complex so it is important to do your homework
It is logical that the problem with untreated wood of any sort is that it will not last as long as chemically treated materials. For more ideas: just google your questions ie "How to Build a Retaining Wall".




In Closing:
There are a couple of very comprehensive articles on the use of materials to use in retaining walls so check them out in Links below. Lots of resources for you to decide what to use in your veggie garden. All very interesting. We have not made our decision yet but hoping these comments have helped others. Best wishes and if you find an economical, organic solution please let me know.
Best Wishes ~ Liz
Links & References:
- "The Safety of Materials Used for Building Raised Beds" (2023) University of Maryland
- "Toxicity Concerns about Raised Bed Construction Materials" Iowa State University
- "Building a landscape Retaining Wall" Lots of helpful information from Oregon State University
Caramel and Parsley:
- "New Raised Bed Gardens for Spring" (2020)
- "Vegetable Gardening on a Steep Slope" (2016)
- Remember to check out Caramel and Parsley's Gardening category with lots of information on how and what to grow in your garden ... thanks ~ Liz







Leave a Reply